Here are some kind words from our wonderful customers!

This place is so nice! I always pass by on the bus on the way home and finally decided to go in one weekend. Everything looks so good, the people were really friendly, and, best of all, the pastries are all delicious! Highly recommend for a wide variety of choices for Italian pastries in a homey environment


Biscotti divine. Every kind of Italian pastry imaginable. Nice family business serving italian ices at very reasonable prices. Don't pass it by.


I have been enjoying there Pastries,Cakes, Cookies & Lemon Ice For 60 years, Just wish they were closer to where I now live, but it’s worth the trip !!!


This is a great pastry shop. I called them looking for a bread round and Darlene was awesome and put one on hold for me. When I arrived, Darlene chatted with me while I gandered at their delicious selection of fresh pastries. Highly recommend this pastry shop!


Absolutely spectacular!!!! I picked up 3 pints of Italian ice, sheet of crumb cake, multiple kinds of cookies & tri color sweets! ( the birthday cake one was delicious ). The employees here were fantastic, helpful and friendly! Fresh bread delivered everyday! The Italian iced are fantastic! Watermelon is my favorite! Go check them out!!!


I really love this bakery. We bring all kinds of goodies from Lyndhurst Bakery to all of our family and friends houses and everyone is always happy. My husband & I had a gender reveal party on Sunday, and I ordered a very custom two tier cake only on Wednesday with no problems. It was perfect! Everything was exactly as we had envisioned & the cake was delicious.


This is place has the best cheesecakes in town. Especially, I am not a big fan of the blueberry cheesecake but they make the best ones. Everything seems like homemade and so tasty. Even I tried their sample chocolate chip cookie and it was extremely delicious. I highly recommend this pastry shop in Lyndhurst!
Thank you!

Can I give 10 stars!? Out of this world Italian ice. I never ever willingly just go out for Italian ice. We were stuck in traffic and my husband mentioned this place and I gave it a shot. I am so glad that I said yes.

Even now I'm sitting here dreaming of that Italian ice.


My Grandmother Florence Moderelli lived on Freeman Street her whole life. I grew up eating pastries and Italian ice from the pastry shop. Even though I live in Atlanta now my kids ask every trip to go to the pastry shop. It's a special tradition that I have passed on to my kids. We love the Lyndhurst Pastry Shop!